This can keep you busy for a very long time. "American Fathers" works better before "A Fine Night of Debauchery" because of dialogue hinting at Arthur visiting Cornwall's factory in the Heartlands during his encounter with Desmond Blythe. Also, this is subjective, but there's no line even hinting that robbing the Valentine bank could screw up the ongoing plans with the Grays (only mention I saw was Arthur reminding Bill that they've 'got irons in' the Gray/Braithwaite plot already), it sort of feels to me like this comes before the meat of the Grays/Braithwaites gets started and as a capstone of 'unfinished business from Valentine' before the gang sinks their teeth into the Rhodes plot. Over a million people still die annually of tuberculosis today. This mission and the two following it are basically all about finding and rescuing Jack, which all occurs in a single day. Yeah, I noticed the dialogue referring to other missions a lot more in RDR. Perhaps there was a time limit? How do duels work in Red Dead Redemption 2? of course Strauss knew about the illness. Perhaps a day of facing down with a giant bear, Arthur would be partial to a drop of whisky? But all of that is up to you of course. Red Dead Redemption 2 story: 5 quests for post epilogue - Red Bull The Red Dead Redemption 2 can be played in both First Person Shooter and Third Persons Shooter mode, a plus point. Edith Downes | Red Dead Wiki | Fandom Coupled with a few other references, I'm not sure that "Peacemakers" should be positioned after "Tobacco" and "Horse Flesh" - the meat of the gang's involvement in the Gray/Braithwaite feud. Was this a blind spot by Rockstar in writing the mission as if the fishing mission had already been done? I went back to camp and read the letter from Mary and then the cut scene with Strauss activated right after. Do Not Seek Absolution - 1. For starting this mission you will have to meet Micah Bell in Annesburg. 2022 - 2023 Times Mojo - All Rights Reserved I hadn't thought about that. I've restarted chapter 2 multiple times to try and get the best RP experience out of the game. Comment document.getElementById("comment").setAttribute( "id", "eb1d0f0d1142f08341a9b2a63514f196" );document.getElementById("d386d3c936").setAttribute( "id", "comment" ); Crisis Core -Final Fantasy VII- Reunion Trophy Guide. These checklists are basically challenges which require you to complete missions do certain tasks. Press J to jump to the feed. In the Saint DenisRead More How do I complete the Mission "Do Not Seek Absolution - I"? Once you do, he'll give you three targets, and even if you try to get smart and only do the other two, eventually he'll remind you of Downes, and the mission begins automatically. But man players such as I enjoy playing in a way that allows you to experience the story in the most logical and cinematic fashion possible. Red Dead Redemption 2 Mrs Downes - Where is She? Ultimately, the game suggests that Arthur was doomed even if he had never contracted Tuberculosis. Press J to jump to the feed. I wonder if he knew that Thomas had tuberculosis? Powered by Invision Community. It can't really be a mid-chapter plot device, because it seems like it's dependent upon "Magicians for Sport" (if I'm interpreting the Red Dead wikia correctly), so the Gray/Braithwaite plot is already really going. Back to Gamorrah" should be labeled for Bill. SPOILER !!! Similarly, in Chapter 2 you can get Lenny back at Horseshoe Overlook before rescuing Sean, and thus maybe get more dialogue/character development during Sean's party. ": Some odd dialogue in this one. With this list, Im attempting to alleviate this issue as much as possible while staying true to the narrative. Keep using the Eagle Eye to be sure that you are following them. No matter which way its cut, the second Arthur Morgan extorts the Downes family in Red Dead Redemption 2s second chapter, he is as good as dead, and theres no way for players to cure his tuberculosis in RDR2. Before any more can be said, Susan Grimshaw shoots Molly in the stomach with a shotgun, killing her instantly. "An Honest Mistake" (Cornwall's agents play a major role) -> "Magicians For Sport" (Hey, Trelawney mentioned bounty hunters, Dutch is antsy about that because Cornwall is being more persistent about crossing state lines than anyone else before) -> The Braithwaite/Gray feud missions, since the bounty hunters were taken care of. This series of quests cannot be started until Chapter 5 and after the "A Fork in the Road" missionwhen Arthur, in Saint Denis, learns he has contracted tuberculosis is completed. She tells him that Archie is probably working in the mines, and also that Archie's foreman and other miners dislike Archie. While I absolutely agree about the three threads happening in that chapter, it seems more like those two at least should happen along with "The Course of True Love" as a lead-in to the Clemens Point chapter. !!! [72] [LS] Money Lending and Other Sins [VI], [75] [LS] Money Lending and Other Sins [VII], [78] [ED] Do Not Seek Absolution [II], [79] [T] The Fine Art of Conversation, [83] [SA] Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow [I-II]. For that reason, I feel they are important to experience. Do Not Seek Absolution is a multi-part side mission available in Red Dead Redemption 2. Arthur expresses surprise that Bill has been drinking with the Grays, and Bill's mention of 'extra security' could be a lead-in to "Short Walk" - bit given Bill's presence with Dutch and Sheriff Gray at the beginning of "Distillation" and the pretext of drinking in the intro to that mission, Arthur shouldn't be all that surprised? Before I saw the mission I had maximum high honor and still have. Funny little detail, if you take the debt quest from Strauss where you have to colect a debt from a miner in Anesburg called Arthur, and if you do that quest before you meet Edith Dowens in Anesburg. Started my 2nd playthrough this morning, following this guide. How do you persuade Edith Downes? - emojicut.com I remember seeing a stranger mission from Edith Downes in Annesburg some time ago, but now it's gone. In this instance, I chose to do "The Aftermath of Genesis" first. I'll definitely be giving this a go after I'm done with my first playthrough. Unfortunately, many of these side missions can be missed if you don't do them . Additionally, they both take place in Saint Denis, so if you want to avoid long travel distances, its best to do them before the gang moves further north. You cannot proceed beyond chapter 2 if youre not doing that mission. Make . [59] [D] A Kind and Benevolent Despot, [61] [X] Paradise Mercifully Departed. I don't know if that line is context-dependent; "extra security" is vague and seems to relate more to "Short Walk", but also could be the lead-in to becoming deputies. How do I complete the Mission "Do Not Seek Absolution - I"? Red Dead Redemption 2 Chapter 6 Beaver Hollow Walkthrough Guide Sean is back, morale is high, so now is the perfect time for a two-day hunting trip with Hosea. I saw that mission on the second play through and tried to skip but I had no more missions left. She tells him to go away and Arthur tells her that he is sorry for what he did and wonders where her son is. Is there a proper earth ground point in this switch box? By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. The first two parts of the mission merge into one. Edith Downes had one of the darkest stories in Red Dead Redemption 2, but at least she got the chance at a better life in the end. This is a good time to finish up anything you might have missed that you want to do, because the story momentum really picks up after this, and never really slows down. Originally I had "Money Lending and Other Sins [III]" occur after "We Loved Once and True," but it turns out that the game will not allow this to happen. I haven't returned to camp yet, went to the trapper near Van Horn to sell the bear pelt first, then to the stables near Dewberry Creek to upgrade my horse tack. I've found that as long as you make an effort to spend time at camps and talk to the gang when you can, it helps flesh out the story/world even if it's just a little. Edith forgiving Arthur can be one of the lines he reflects upon during his last ride. However, players should note that the latter can sometimes be acquirable with the corresponding amount of positive . Just sleep in a tent or hotel etc., until you're done doing everything else that can be finished east of Blackwater, because once Arthur reads the letter, the cutscene triggers and game progression is forced by the evil Austrian. I noticed that there is another little bit in Annesburg later and wondered if your choice effected that. Every time I see him I antagonize him as much as I can, its pretty fun. I'm conscious that Miss Grimshaw will accost me with Hosea's message when I go back, and there are no strangers or anything major to distract Arthur between Dewberry Creek and Horseshoe Overlook. At this time, the gang members havent caused enough trouble to be noticed by local law enforcement, allowing them to freely meddle with the Grays and the Braithwaites. Also worth mentioning - if you do another mission after PFO II (in which you're supposed to steal the oil wagon), the game will skip straight to PFO III and John will accuse Arthur of forgetting about the oil wagon, but not to worry because he's taken care of it. Edith Downes is the widow of Thomas Downes in Red Dead Redemption 2, but her bad luck doesnt stop when her husband dies. You can justify meeting them later, but there is no reason for the Reverend to be sitting around at the train station for days waiting for you to arrive. After initially paying a visit to Mr. Downes, who is sickly and poor, Arthur discovers . The boys can wait. Red Dead Redemption 2 Mrs Downes Story Explained I was fine, getting so much done and went ahead and got Kieran untied and Sean out of BW. In Sadie's mission, he asks Sadie to help the Marstons as well, which I find makes more sense if he already talks to John about escaping. SPOILER WARNING !!! Jack is Johns son, but Arthur clearly had a massive influence on him. Intervene - beat the foreman. What I mean is this:-, - 'Polite Society Valentine Style' seems to me like the most obvious one to do first because dialogue in this one suggests that this is Arthur's first trip into Valentine and it just feels like this is the intro mission to this chapter, - After you finish this mission you can return the horse you borrowed to it's owner which puts you back in Valentine with 'Americans At Rest' just around the corner soit makes sense to do that next. I think you know what I was trying to say, though. In 1907, Edith and her son are seen boarding a ship in the Saint Denis harbor, their appearances implying they are wealthier than before. "A Short Walk in a Pretty Town" should be labeled for Bill. PC Stadia Xbox One. Do Not Seek Absolution - II is the 70th main story mission in Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2). Summary; Coughing blood is one of the major signs of TB, so not only did this confirm that Thomas Downes was sick, but it also confirms he was who gave Arthur TB, since coughing infected blood in someones face is a sure-fire way to give them tuberculosis in RDR2 as well as in real life. @Spydr WebzReally liking your order after reading through it! Arthur later learns how Edith earned enough money to settle her husband's death. Here's my revise versions of chapters 2-3, Chapter one is perfect so no need to change, [LS] Money Lending and Other Sins [I-II], [LS] Money Lending and Other Sins [III], As you can see nothing is changed except for "Money lending and other sins" since you can do all of them back to back, Part 1: Is a stand alone mission for Sadie since you only work with her once, [P] Further Questions of Female Suffrage, Part 2: It's all about the gray / braithwaites feud, [A] Advertising the New American Art [I-II], Part 5: The fallout of the gray /braithwaites feud, Has anybody tried maximizing dialogue options by doing quests in a specific order? Of course, RDR2 is an open, non-linear game at times, so any player is free to play how they choose and at their own pace. If the player reaches an honor rank of -4 (low honor), the "Gunslinger Ebony Grip", exclusive to the Double-action Revolver, becomes available for purchase. -Good, Honest Snake Oil is not a required mission to progress in the story. Mutually exclusive execution using std::atomic? I went to Sadie then did all the Edith Downesmissions in Annesburg where you get her and her son to leave, then I did the Dutch mission when you set up the beavers hollow camp and at the end of thatmission you see Edith walk into a shack with a man. I'm pretty confused here. Did this satellite streak past the Hubble Space Telescope so close that it was out of focus? Hosea would need time to return to camp, then head to Emerald Ranch and discover Seamus's little side business, as well as time to pass along a message to Miss Grimshaw about sending Arthur to meet him. If you camp overnight, that should be sufficient for the waypoint to appear on your map. -UPDATE:Originally I put "Fisher of Men" after "Pouring Forth Oil [IV]." Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. AFoM unlocked for me right after PFO III, so it can be done in this order. Theres no way to save Arthur in Red Dead Redemption 2. However, he was unable to repay the loan, leading to Arthur Morgan being sent to the ranch by Strauss in the hope of forcing Thomas to repay his debt . helping people in random encounters or by making honorable decisions in missions that are part of chapter 5 and 6. However, after playing though it once, it becomes rather simple to piece the missions together into a more coherent and logical narrative. Let me know if you think I got something wrong here. Arthur later learns how Edith earned enough money to settle her husbands death. Itll save you a trip to do both the same day; just make sure you start with Of Men and Angels.. These thoughts are really disorganized, apologies for that, I'll consolidate them more once I've finished up the chapter and can note dialogue oddities in the remaining missions. Edith is the wife of Thomas Downes and the mother of Archie Downes. However, I think they both do a terrific job of actually showing us Arthurs desire to redeem himself in the face of his lethal condition. Both are sensitive, both like reading, both like writing, and both are inherently artistic folk. It's all useless. The website that quote is from also lists the different Stranger . Actually reading yourmission order for chapter 5 I do think youre suppose to see Dutch to do Thats MurfreeCountry before doing the balloonmission and finding out Arthur has TB. There are quite a lot of these in total. As part of this mission, Arthur tries to help Edith Downes and her son Archie find a peaceful life. After being helped to a clinic by a stranger, Arthur learns from the doctor that he has contracted tuberculosis, which is terminal and will ultimately kill him. Edith and her son become financially unstable, resulting in Edith becoming a prostitute in Saint Denis to support her and Archie. She and her son pack up and leave the homestead, intending to start a new life elsewhere. This was great. Though the wiki lists that mission as a main mission, it's shown as a stranger mission in rdr2. Thomas Downes first appears upon the player's first visit to Valentine, to which he can be found near the stables opening a fundraiser for . Watch the cut-scene. -Exit, Pursued by a Bruised Ego fits best after The First Shall Be Last, because after the latter mission, there is a break in the narrative where Arthur has no other obligations to anyone or anything. He denies this being a revenge operation. Maybe having a calmer mission in between "Peacemakers" and "Short Walk" would fit? There's a ton of Hosea and Dutch / Hosea and Abigail (and Jack) / Hosea and John conversations that can take place in camp, most of which I've seen before doing any missions in Chapter 2. Hidden Easter eggs, cut game-file content and much more! Therefore, "Fisher of Men" should occur before the train robbery. Quest Giver: Edith Downes (Archie Downes) How can I get the Edith Downes stranger mission? What happened to penelope braithwaite? Explained by Sharing Culture Does Counterspell prevent from any further spells being cast on a given turn? Most of them occur at night as well, so note that you can spend the day doing other things instead of triggering the missions, and then time-skipping several hours. I did not include the Epilogue in this list because it's too straightforward and simple to have any specific order. [45] [ML] Fatherhood and Other Dreams, [49] [BD] Brothers and Sisters, One and All, [55] [D] Revenge is a Dish Best Eaten, [56] [D] Banking, the Old American Art. Details on missions will be hidden, so only mission names will be visible unless you wish to view details and notes. Arthur is then chased away by the police. Arthur finds her talking with a client and promptly scares him off. -Like the first one, chapter five is pretty straightforward and linear. Wait for the second quest marker to appear in Annesburg. Log in to add games to your lists. Filed Under: Game Guides, Red Dead Redemption 2. Complete with at least 70% accuracy. [28] [P] Further Questions of Female Suffrage, [30] [GR] The Course of True Love [I-II], [30] - [GR] - The Course of True Love [III], [30] [A] Advertising the New American Art [I-II], [36] [L] Preaching Forgiveness as He Went, [40] [D] Blood Feuds, Ancient and Modern. Red Dead Redemption 2 Mrs Downes appears in a secret side mission . (Bear in mind that I haven't actually finished the chapter yet, so if there's, say, no timeskip between this chapter and the next that makes a bit more narrative sense.) He also tries to offer her money, but she refuses to accept it. Im late to this but I havent completed the last 2 money lending missions with Lilly millet and I think the other guy was called pip or chip I also havent completed the 2nd Micah mission and Im in chapter 3 Ill see if I can go to chapter 4 maybe with just the those 2 missions. Go back with the widow to Annesburg. If you made "bad" decisions, try increasing your honor by, i.e. Find Edith Downes within 1 minute and 10 seconds. 20181030Rockstar Games27 . All Red Dead Redemption 2 (Rdr2) Gold Medal Objectives List 2021 Once the player reaches rank 4, the Heros Pearl Grip for the Cattleman Revolver becomes available. -Thread II: American Distillation through Horse Flesh for Dinner make up the second thread of missions, which focus on the gangs interference in the local family feud. I'd seen the ED, and a couple of other side mission markers come and go a number of times before I visited And triggered them. This isn't really a mystery or Easter egg, just optional honor missions. Watch the cut-scene. Upd 2: "Short Walk in a Pretty Town" through "The Battle of Shady Belle". EDIT 3: Sorry for all the edits, I'm really enjoying myself. Guides. I compiled this order as I played through the game for the first time, noting areas where the narrative didnt make sense or had less of a cinematic impact, and then reconfigured the order to better achieve the goal. GTANet.com 2001-2023. This pagegives which missions unlock which newspapers, so - assuming newspaper content is fixed and not contextual like some dialogue lines - that might be a good indicator of which missions take place between the missions that trigger papers, based on which articles track with missions Arthur does. 3 "Money Lending and Other Sins" sidemissions, since Strauss will have had time to shark and pay attention to his connections, as he learned that Downes died. Watch the cut-scene. Icarus and Friends; Visiting Hours; Just a Social Call; . What does help though with projects like thisis that cutscenes will sort of push you in a certain direction when you have multiple missions to chase after. Originally I put "Fisher of Men" after "Pouring Forth Oil [IV]." -------------------------------------------------------------------------. After an examination of his ear, breathing, and mouth, Arthur is then given the diagnosis of tuberculosis. To start, talk to Strauss, who gives you details about the three people he wants you to visit. . If so, how close was it? More. Red Dead Redemption 2 Do Not Seek Absolution - II Walkthrough - PowerPyx To get the Gold Medal for this mission, you must complete it within 1 minute and 20 seconds, which is more than doable if you skip all cutscenes. Do you thinkthis an error in the order of missions, or was Arthur referring to Jimmy Brooks outside of Valentine? Due to Arthur beating up Thomas Downes, who has Tuberculosis, under Leopold Strauss orders, while Arthur held him up against the fence, Downes coughs on him, which causes him to receive Tuberculosis. Add this game to my: Favorite Games. Skip the opening cinematic. After beating RDR2's single-player campaign, the so-called "post game" can extend well beyond the conclusion of Epilogue II, with Red Dead 2's endgame giving you the option to go back and complete . Start following it. Arthur Morgan originally encounters the Downes family in the Horseshoe Overlook chapter of Red Dead Redemption 2. Red Dead Redemption 2: Do Not Seek Absolution - walkthrough, map November 16, 2018 in Red Dead Redemption 2, !!! Do Not Seek Absolution is a multi-part side mission available in Red Dead Redemption 2. behaved justly during the game. Do Men Still Wear Button Holes At Weddings? Oooooh I'm in. However, it is necessary to complete in this chapter if one wants a good introduction into bounty hunting side missions. RDR2's Most Tragic Character Actually Has A Happy Ending, RDR2: What Dutch Was Doing Between Red Dead Redemption Games, RDR2's Horse Realism In Cold Weather Goes Deeper Than Players Thought, Why Kevin Costner Leaving Yellowstone Will Make The Show Better, New Stephen King Movie Adaptation Decimated By Critics, South Park Just Took The Weirdest Real-Life Issue Seriously. Follow Dutch up to the mining operation by the tracks. While it does seem strange to leave Swanson at the station for a day or 2, one thing I've noticed is that when you return him if you speak with Grimshaw afterwards she says "It looks like he's been up for days!" Which Teeth Are Normally Considered Anodontia. Edith eventually gives Arthur the money when he comesasking for it though its unclear at that point where the money came from but she curses him out before he leaves. For example, in Chapter 2 Hosea is not available for gang conversation from after you complete the first mission until after you complete Spines of America, when he returns to camp. John's line in "The Battle of Shady Belle" commenting on the futility of the deaths the gang's caused in pursuit of this feud-meddling, but specifically naming the timeframe as "the last few weeks", the same rough period as Arthur's recovery (were it to happen immediately previous) but Arthur doesn't defer, which has me going back to my initial feeling of "Peacemakers" being more of a mid-chapter break mission, then the gang has lied low enough (and Dutch and Bill have charmed their way into Sheriff Gray's continued good graces) for things to die down until they make too much trouble, but specificallytoo close to Rhodes - and that leads the Pinkertons to them, as shown in "Battle for Shady Belle".